Frumster Marketing: How to get the most out of your profile!

by Heshy Fried on February 20, 2008 · 35 comments

I got this idea while reading the Frumster Shoppers blog post on venturing out of ones hashkafic realm on frumster.

I would call myself an experienced Frumster dabbler, I was member when it was completely free, I was a pissed off member when they started charging and I have done my fare share of “temporary profile removal” during positive looking relationships. Through all of my frumster history I have learned several things, first of all that just making a profile, uploading your picture and looking through profiles is nice, but it is not all there is to it. This informative post is all about frumster market research, and how to get the most out of your frumster profile, because although they claim 50 are married every month- I noticed that you weren’t married.

Self description:

For much of my life on frumster I had an obscenely long profile. You all know what I am talking about, usually it is the weirdos and eccentrics that do this. First their hobbies and interests take up half a page and then you are greeted with 3 pages of descriptions, quotes and cheesy poetry. For most people, obviously not including me- this is where they click out of the profile. People have a short attention span and you are trying to sell yourself, you cannot do that with a very long profile. With that said, if the description of the person was less then one full paragraph I almost always clicked out. Another red flag for me is when the profile starts like this “I am really new at this and I don’t want to sound like an egotistical person” but here goes…. That is probably the common similarity between profiles.

Actually I usually clicked out after reading hobbies and interests that had anything to do with going to the mall, shopping, tanning, hanging out with friends, going online, talking on the phone and only simchas browsing. This was my red flag, as well as hobbies that were the prerequisite for admittance into the top seminaries, like cooking, cleaning, shietle shopping, and baby breathing practices. Don’t get me wrong, a girl who can cook is prime, but if it is followed by those sort of kollel wife keywords I wanted nothing to do with it.

I am definitely not the right person to tell you how to utilize the box for the description of self and mate. But do use capitalization, full sentences and please avoid, especially if you are over 20, the use of words like b4, u, ur, lol, cuz, btw, um, and i- I understand that many are likely to criticize me for saying this due to my poor grammar skills, BUT, I never use words like those that are used for quick text messaging. Ladies, please sound like you are mature enough to pop out children and know what a mortgage is.

How to Label yourself:
I think it may have been frumster that originally split up modern orthodoxy into two groups. Originally those who wanted to cover their hair were lumped in with those folks who felt that modern orthodoxy had a leniency for eating milchigs out and having proms at their yeshiva high schools. Then frumster came along and invented Modern Orthodox Machmir and Liberal. Right away you could see the differences, it was as simple as Teanack and the Upper West Side vs. Washington Heights and Kew Garden Hills, brilliance- oh and it gave me so much more material as well.

As a side note don’t think by writing “labels are for can” or “I don’t like boxing myself in” that you are being original. You are not, in fact you are so typical- they should have a category called “I’m not your typical (circle your choice) girl.” The girls who usually have to say they are not your typical fill in the blank girls- are Stern, Brooklyn, Five Towns, Shulamis, and Bais Yaakov. Usually they may throw in something like “out of townish” attitude- red flags for me.

The two largest categories on frumster also happen to be these so tread lightly. I was placed by my hashkafic values and years of honing my “out of the box” attitude or as they say in frum communities he is “open minded” which I never understood because that is like saying, all those that are not modern orthodox are closed minded- and suddenly instead of being my cool out of the box type I was thrust into a world of normalcy, for I became modern orthodox machmir. Well actually my economic theorizing brought me to the conclusion that the largest category and most searched throughout frumster would be that one and therefore, purely for marketing purposes I chose that one. My theories proved to be correct, and I enjoyed the freedom of girls looking at my profile, instead of being cast aside like those of the Shomer Mitzvot category- which I could never really understand why they were different then any other sort of orthodoxy. I came to the conclusion that they had the same hashkafa as yeshivish modern, but instead of using the “suf” they sounded things with a “tuf”- basically they said Shabbat shalom instead of gut shabbos.

Later on in the frumster market research project I came to the conclusion that modern orthodox machmir and liberal sometimes ventured out of their hashkafic realm, as I noticed myself becoming bored with my group and started venturing to the shomer mitzvoth, carlebachian and even yeshivish modern. I had an idea, I had had enough of the cookie cutter “I want a normal guy” profiles of the machmir crowd, they all had something claiming not be the typical (insert place or institution) girl. Like I am not your typical Brooklyn, Stern, Shulamis, Upper West Side- girl, followed by a brilliantly mass produced profile that sounded exactly like all the others.

“I have never done this before and don’t want to sound egotistical, but here goes… my friends think I am…” Then there would be a bunch of ordinary descriptive words that her friends tell her she is. Well that’s great honey, but how about telling me about yourself, your friends would never tell you the truth anyway. The ending would always be “I just cant seem to find a normal guy.”

So you can see why I had to leave the world of Touro grads who wanted to become speech pathologist, physical therapists and occupational therapists- solely for the purpose of baby making and stay at home momdom. I wanted something more, I needed passion, so naturally I went for the weirdoes. I ventured into the Carlebachian and Hassidish- which on frumster means ex-Charedim and Lubavitchers- for all you who are not inclined to click outside your hashkafic realm.

Suddenly I had an idea, if I was leaving the modern orthodox machmir ghetto for greener pastures, others were doing the same and since categories like Shomer Mitzvot and Carlebachian were rather small, maybe two pages of profiles- that means that all of them would get looked at, and that raised my chances of being found in the see of good looking investment bankers and balding, potbellied flakey Jake shabbaton attendees. So I made the switch to Shomer Miztvot, which I found kind of hard cause I knew more then anyone that I was not shomer mitzvoth, yes I did keep the main stuff, but I rarely said shema on time and never did the targum part of shnyim mikra v’echad targum, that stuff would just have to be left out of my secret life until the third date or so.

Suddenly my world opened up and there were hundreds more girls looking at my profile every day, the emails started flowing in, albeit from some pretty weird girls, but my marketing move was successful. Use the categories to your advantage.

Body Type:

Look I don’t want to talk about this because I know many of my friends and readers are of the bigger type. I myself have been attracted to and dated what one may call “chunky” girls, so I am not knocking the curvy type, but pay heed because unfortunately most guys are not like me, most guys weed out the frumster profiles in the master search by choosing average, athletic and slim- thereby avoiding all of you gals and guys that tell the truth. Average is very ambiguous, what average are we talking about here anyway? I know a girl that wrote average and she was well over two hundred pounds and of a guy who had a 32 waist and wrote average- so you see my friends- at least you get some traffic.

Now I am not telling you to lie, by all means put up a realistic picture of yourself. I find that even though I hit the profile because they wrote average, if the picture does not suit my needs, I click away- unless the profile is amazing- which sometimes it is. Putting a normal picture- without the “frumster effect” is important to me. The frumster effect is when you have no idea what their body looks like, either they are bending down- almost always in some sort of wedding picture, or they are standing diagonal in a darkened hallway, they are all false advertising. Many frumster pictures remind me of those fast diet ads that show two images both before and after “she lost 59 pounds” and I swear that they are never the same person- or they can really suck that tummy in.

I used to write average, then I switched to athletic, I liked how it sounded better, and I could get away with it. As long as they didn’t see me with my shirt off, it was all good. Average is the best way to go, because pretty much everyone on frumster is average, which judging by the obesity issues that face our gluttonous Kiddush club society is beyond that of the national average, unless you happen to be in the deep south where fat is a way of life.

Stalking:

I am sure we can argue all day long about the merits of the frumster “who has looked at your profile” feature. I used to love it because it allowed me to gauge my progress, were people actually looking at me, or was it the same folks over and over again, begging for me to look at theirs signaling something similar to that of a note being passed from the girl to a guy in opposing sides of the dance floor at a bar mitzvah.

I like it because you can see who looked at you, click on them and if they or you are interested- your profile was fresh in their mind, it also happens to be that although we are adults, the ladies still like to be contacted. They like to show you who’s boss or something, although several months back before my previous relationship I was going through a hot streak in which tons of girls were emailing me, unfortunately they were ones that try every six months to get me to go out with them- and I hate to block- it seems so cruel.

On the other hand, this feature allows people to see when folks looked at their profile. So for instance after a shabbaton I went to, this girl I met with and I guess flirted with- although I flirt and have no idea I am doing it- was always the last person to look at my profile. I refused to give in to her stalking motives, because I knew once I clicked the profile, I would receive a message. It went on for several months and stopped all the sudden, presumably she gave up, because I was about to email her and tell her, I wished to see some other girls as the last girl who looked at me.

Then of course you have situations when you want to show your friend the profile of a girl who just contacted you and was extremely weird, but you realize that she will see you are clicking on her a bunch of times, and start to dream of all the kinderlach you will have together.

My frumster status:

I haven’t reactivated my profile, because Facebook has had a proliferation of shidduch clubs, where people just stand around and don’t write on the wall for some reason or another. Then of course there has been a proliferation of shidduch blogs, mostly by angsty young girls who are pissed off that all their friends are getting married and they are stuck in the “shidduch parshah”, and of course I like to save money and if I meet people on frumster I have to go through the painful device of whether to tell them about my blog before they google me and go nuts. So I have not reactivated my account on frumster and it lies in its dust waiting to be revived.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
Possibly related posts:

{ 2 trackbacks }

Ripping apart a crazy BT frumster profile | Frum Satire | Jewish Comedy
December 7, 2008 at 2:36 AM
Frumster introduces pickup lines | Frum Satire | Jewish Comedy
February 12, 2009 at 2:09 PM

{ 33 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Ben-Yehudah February 20, 2008 at 7:51 PM

B”H Well, I guess it’s time for me to write “that” post finally. I posted a proposed ad on the Hashkafah.com Forum, to get some feedback. The feedback from men was OK.

The M/O women and formerly frum women hated it of course.

The whole hair covering thing… I said yes to hair covering (duh) and no to sheitels, skirts above the knee, low neck lines, short sleeves. You got the picture.

They said I can’t dictate what my wife should do…. I won’t bore your readers with the reinventing of this thread. Been there, done that. If you don’t like it, then I’m obviously not the guy for you. Don’t marry me, and let’s move on. They wouldn’t let it go.

Finally I asked them if they noticed that I never mentioned physical appearance. I said that since men are always supposed to be objectifying women’s bodies, I should get points for not doing so. They decision was, yeah, I did deserve points for that, but only a few.

Meanwhile this self identified frum women writes me a message saying that she agreed with me. We both decided that we weren’t compatible for other reasons, and wish each other success.

How many responses do you think I’ll get if I say I expect my wife to wear a veil? Not many, huh? ;-)

Reply

2 heshman February 20, 2008 at 8:35 PM

Well with the whole burqua movement in Charediville heating up the veil thing may not be so far off.

If your trying to find a shidduch- I would say that Facebook with its proliferation of shidduch clubs- is the place to be.

Reply

3 Keeping up with the Frieds February 20, 2008 at 11:33 PM

Speaking of frumster status…

…Hesh, what’s your status?

Reply

4 heshman February 21, 2008 at 12:11 AM

My status in terms of what- if you mean in terms of dating- I am a free agent, and people have been contacting me left and right. Oh and I just got a good job.

Reply

5 s(b.) digs B-3 February 21, 2008 at 12:15 AM

mazel tov on the job! you harriman-bound?

Reply

6 heshman February 21, 2008 at 12:20 AM

Finally someone who understands why on earth I of all people would move to Monsey. Oh and Stewart State Forest-12,000 acres of mountain biking less then an hour away.

Oh and tons of great writing material.

Reply

7 Keeping up with the Frieds February 21, 2008 at 12:26 AM

Good job = farm hand?

Reply

8 Booboo February 21, 2008 at 12:33 AM

The problem con facebook is that you can’t click on (read: stalk) people if they don’t have their security settings open, or if they’re in another city/network. What are your thoughts on pokes? Creepy? Acceptable?

Reply

9 Anita February 21, 2008 at 1:31 AM

I was considering on a frumster profile… now I’m scared. lol…I’m actually NOT typical, and I was planning on being “shomer mitzvot” lol…but for real, I’m not typical. No one ever described me as typical, before or after I became frum.

I guess I’ll stick to facebook, but it IS creepy to just randomly stalk people on facebook.

Reply

10 Mindy February 21, 2008 at 3:56 AM

Ben Yehudah- *DO* you plan on your wife wearing a veil?

And how old are you?

Reply

11 Mindy February 21, 2008 at 4:04 AM

Oh and congrats on the job.

Reply

12 Rach February 21, 2008 at 4:52 AM

I totally agree, anyone can pretend to be anything over the net. On one hand its stupid, cos even if your pic makes u look like you’re 100 pounds cos you’re sucking in your cheeks and wearing 5 girdles, and wearing an extra padded bra to make your tummy look smaller (i swear it works, the bigger the boobs, the smaller the stomach looks!), the point is, at the end of the day when u actually meet people off the net, you still qualify for The Biggest Loser. Ten again, that said, if you find someone who likes you enough as a person over the net/phone for your personality, maybe they’ll be so in love with you by the time u meet that they won’t care that you look a BIT different to your frumster picture. They DO say love is blind.

Now with tagging on facebook though, no one can really get away with looking good in all the pictures, if your friend tags you in a pic and u look fat, you’re screwed, and your 110 pound idea self goes down the drain, well that is until u remove the tag, but by that time, who knows how many people have seen the pic…

Reply

13 Powermetal Head / Ben February 21, 2008 at 5:41 AM

The whole facebook thing has gotten crazy. Stupid groups covering every topic under the sun. Stalkers, pokers, spammers. It’s amazing to see in one stupid hook-up group how many jews really have lost any connection. 44,000 people in a few hours.

Reply

14 Rach February 21, 2008 at 6:14 AM

think, like anything facebook can be a good or stupid/bad thing. i have friends all over the world as a result of travelling and of my friends travelling, and coming from aust which is quite far away nt to mention the time difference, so facebook allows me to connect with my friends quickly and easily on a daily basis and check out what thyre up to. A few of my old school friends have also recently found me using facebook, which is cute, its great to catch up with them, see what twists and turns their lives have taken. i COULD join 500 groups and waste 10 hours a day facebooking but i dont… i waste time on this site instead haha, jk im loving this site otherwise i wouldnt be here!

Reply

15 s(b.) February 21, 2008 at 7:20 AM

I thought Carlebachian meant neo-Breslov music lovers and other non-dirty non-hippies. I haven’t looked at what mine says in a while. Maybe I’ll do that, some time.

Reply

16 heshman February 21, 2008 at 12:40 PM

Maybe I will do a thoughts on facebook post. I do wonder if any of you understood the wit and subtle humor contained in this post. It seems like many people glazed over it or its not worth commenting.

That aside, I am not creeped out by any of that stuff. I worked as a Private Investigator for a year- paid to stalk insurance cheaters- talk about creepy.

Reply

17 RE February 21, 2008 at 1:01 PM

I also worked as a private investigator and it changed a lot about the way I saw people. Only I was investigating employees that stole and cheating spouses, so it got a little depressing.

That aside, I did enjoy this post – it’s funny because so much of it is true. Regarding picture posting, my personal opinion is that nobody would post a *bad* picture of themselves, it’s always the best possible picture that they have – people spend so much time cropping and selecting their best possible shot, at the most flattering angle. Your so-called “frumster effect” has also become the “facebook effect” – I recently went on a trip that had a fb group set up before we left so that we could contact each other, but the actual group wasn’t nearly 1/2 as good looking as it was online!

Reply

18 heshman February 21, 2008 at 1:08 PM

I have a good story for you, I had a whole slew of pictures up and I have no clue how to photo shop- anyway I got contacted twice by people who said I should put up more flattering pictures of myself- as not in jeans and fleece- and more of the dressed up variety. Of course I hate dressing up when I don’t have to and enjoy my “same basic outfit” everyday philosophy.

Fellow P.I. huh, so did you enjoy it? Because I did for 6 months then I started freaking out- because I started getting sent to real redneck places- and had to crawl through the woods on my belly to get a clear film of them doing yardwork and stuff.

Reply

19 abandoning eden February 21, 2008 at 1:28 PM

hrm, when i did internet dating I always did a face shot….the idea of posting a whole body shot just never occurred to me. I thought I was supposed to post like yearbook-type pictures (only more recent).

I was on frumster when it first started and it was free. Then this dude I worked with in high school contacted me…he was the manager at the glatt kosher chinese store in monsey I did deliveries at for a summer, and he totally sexually harassed me the whole time i worked there (about 8 weeks). He kept asking me to have sex with him in the bathroom, and would make me squeeze by him to get to the back of the (very small and cramped) kitchen, so that he always ended up feeling me up. He also liked to talk about how he had anal sex with his GF, but that didn’t count as pre-marital sex for some reason. I ended up quitting because of him, cause I told the owner, but god forbid he acknowledge that a so called “religious” jewish person could do anything wrong.

Anyways, like 5 years later, soon after I had joined frumster, he contacted me on frumster and was like “remember me! we should go out sometime”. Apparently he had married the girl he was dating when I knew him (and when he was harassing me) and had later gotten divorced. gross. I canceled my membership that day and have not looked back.

Reply

20 heshman February 21, 2008 at 2:06 PM

Eden I am sorry to hear about your exp in Glatt wok or wherever you worked. I think my ex worked there. Cant say her name here though. She’s 28 so maybe you know her- though I have no idea how old you are.

Yearbook pictures are great, but we need the full thing- at least I like it- unless the girl is super cool then I don’t even need a picture.

Well eden- you can join the facebook proliferation in shidduch dating.

Reply

21 RE February 21, 2008 at 2:35 PM

Were these your friends telling you, or random people online? I guess once you get over the initial shock of someone telling you what pictures to post, then it’s kind of nice of them to look out for you. I absolutely loved this job, but I’m not going to lie – when I thought about the people that I was investigating, it got me pretty down. I mostly worked w/ people that were stealing, so I had to get a special license to detain people. It became problematic when I got someone that didn’t speak english, and I had to give them their rights in my very-broken-and-i’m-not-going-to even-try-to-conjugate-this french!

I’m always curious as to how other people got their PI jobs, since mine was posted under an ‘admin’ cover, how did you get yours?

Reply

22 heshman February 21, 2008 at 3:00 PM

No these were random people who thought I looked like a shlump- anyways I got my job through craigslist and I didn’t get a license- because I never wanted to commit to more then 30 hours a week- nor did I want to get a more generic car.

Reply

23 Ian Anderson February 21, 2008 at 11:00 AM

Hesh I must say that although none of the comments reflect the actual post- it was amazing- it was classic.

I miss your long detailed dry humor posts. You need to do more wedding and shul thoughts posts, and the latest video was brilliant man- I love the licha dodi look back- priceless man.

Reply

24 miriam February 21, 2008 at 11:22 PM

Do you tell ppl on this blog what you are looking for shidduchimwise?

Reply

25 Rach February 22, 2008 at 12:02 AM

y, u interested miriam? :D

Reply

26 Hesh February 22, 2008 at 12:17 AM

The blog has definitely helped my cause, but at the same time- you really cant know the real me from the blog. I use facebook more or less for that.

Reply

27 abandoning eden February 23, 2008 at 11:50 PM

it wasn’t glatt wok, although I did work at glatt wok too for a few months. :)

I’m happily coupled now, so I have no need for facebook shidduch dating. :) I didn’t even know that existed really… I use facebook to catch up on how many kids the girls I went to high school with have now. :)

Reply

28 Rach February 24, 2008 at 12:15 AM

was there life before kids? there must be cos im kidless and guess what, im alive!

Reply

29 Hesh February 24, 2008 at 12:21 AM

Abandoning Eden- how old are you? We could probably play some mad Jewish Geography- you should start a facebook profile for your blog- always interesting.

The g Chinese restaurants in Monsey suck- because when they serve broccoli it is without the florets- it bothers me to no avail.

Reply

30 abandoning eden February 24, 2008 at 12:50 AM

I’m 25..graduated high school in 2000.

I have a facebook profile for myself. Do you have one specifically for your blog? I can friend you with my real name and we can play the 6 degrees of jewish facebook :) (just don’t give away my secret real identity! :lol: )

I actually like the broccoli without the florets better :) And I love how they had that great veal that was red on the sides…soo good.

Reply

31 Hesh February 24, 2008 at 1:18 AM

My facebook name is Frum Satire and I can keep your identity secret.

Reply

32 urban gypsy May 8, 2008 at 1:05 PM

hi hesh,

i’ve been a longtime lurker and viewer of your blog and youtube videos, and i love your work. this is the first time i’ve been compelled to comment because i have a serious question for you.

you mentioned that “we need the full thing- at least I like it- unless the girl is super cool then I don’t even need a picture. ” i am new to frumster (and internet dating in general!) and i feel a bit awkward about putting together a profile.

can you be straight with me, and tell me what catch the attention of a cool guy like you in a profile? i am a hobby snob too and have a lot of diverse interests, but just listing them off in a single breath seems more appropriate for facebook than frumster. can you give me some hints of how to present a unique and interesting profile without being too obscure or alienating people right off the bat?

thanks alot and keep up the great work :)

Reply

33 heshman May 8, 2008 at 1:12 PM

well urban gypsy I think you should email me- frumsatire@gmail.com

Here’s the deal- very long profiles scare people- moderately long but very descriptive are the best. In terms of hobbies- I write about 6 or 7 of them. My profile is outdoorjew- you should check it out.

I also dont like cliche things like “My friends tell me I am…” Or “I never really did this before but here goes” to me these are confidence issues- I think confident girls are super sexy so I look into things quite a bit.

contact me for more information- I have just written a post about my going back on frumster, going to post it next week

Reply

Leave a Comment

You can use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Previous post:

Next post: